Noise Nuisance Case.

Noisy neighbour Ewa Walsh

A Nuisance homeowner, who has been keeping her neighbours awake at night by slamming doors and windows and throwing objects against a wall, has been warned she faces a month in prison if the noise continues.

Ewa Walsh claimed it was a draught that caused the doors to slam, and said the noises were “normal living” sounds and not excessive.

Mouse

Walsh, of Dun Saithne Green, Balbriggan, denied she was making excessive noise at her terraced house after her neighbour Liam Coyle brought a civil case of noise pollution against her.

Mr Coyle told the court that he had been living beside the defendant since 2011 and never experienced any issues until last year.

“At all hours of the night – 2am, 3am, 4am and 5am – it’s like she is running through her house, slamming doors and windows and throwing heavy objects against a wall,” said Mr Coyle.

He claimed that during the summer months, when the defendant was leaving her home, she would excessively rev her SUV.

He said the noise stopped and she was “quiet as a mouse” after their last court date but then in early December the noise started again.

“I have kept a log and sound recordings of it,” he said, adding that he has a partner and a young child who are kept awake by the excessive noise.

“I would like to get a night’s sleep.”

However, Ms Walsh claimed that the building quality of the terraced houses was very bad.

“If you close a door, everyone hears it. I don’t do this on purpose,” she said.

“His wife bangs on my door as well. Sometimes the draught between doors causes them to slam.”

She also asked: “What does it mean by excessive noise?”

Judge Dermot Dempsey found her guilty of making excessive noise and warned her that if it continued at its current volume, she will end up in prison.

“Monitor the situation for one month and there better be no repetition of noise – otherwise I am dealing with it,” said Judge Dempsey.

He adjourned the case until February 21.

 

Noisy Neighbours UK – Our Survey Results Revealed

Background and Purpose
Initial Findings
Regional Data
Benchmarking Data
Inherent Variation
Future Developments

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Our 2014 Noisy Neighbours UK survey revealed some interesting information about the numbers of noise complaints being received by local authorities in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. We asked each local authority in the UK how many noise complaints they received, how much enforcement action they took and about officer staffing levels.  Data was provided by 340 respondents out of the 374 local authorities in England, Wales and Northern Ireland (a response rate of 91%). During the course of the research we have compared the data received to government data and national indicies; and are able to outline some interesting findings (due to differing noise enforcement mechanisms in Scotland we excluded their data from the survey).

As well as locating the UK’s noisiest local authority areas our survey set out to determine whether we were able to make any meaningful comparison between local authority noise complaint and enforcement activity.

INITIAL FINDINGS

422,250 noise complaints were received by local authorities responding to the survey (predominantly environmental health departments) in the 2013-2014 financial period.

On average 1.7 abatement notices were served by each Council (for noise) for every 100 complaints received. 24 Councils were identified as having served no notices at all. There were an average of 3.85 officers working in each Borough each responsible for investigating an average of 385 complaints. Many of these officers were responsible for carrying out a number of other tasks in addition to noise investigations.

With the data we were able to rank local authority areas in terms of the number of complaints received and rate of enforcement action taken. Some regional data is available below. The results provide an initial snapshot of how local authority areas compare regionally.

 

To find out more, click here.